State Records Committee Appeal Decision Summaries, 1992-1994
The full decision and order is available by following the case number link. See also cases from 1995-1997, 1998-2000, 2001-2003, 2004-2006, 2007-2009, 2010-2012, and 2013-2015.
Search Decisions and Orders:
| Case Number | Case Title/Participants | Records Sought | Ruling |
|---|---|---|---|
| 92-01 | Salt Lake Tribune vs. Utah Dept. of Transportation |
Traffic accident database | Appeal partially granted |
| 92-02 | Deseret News vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety, Driver's License Division |
Driving records [fee waiver] | Appeal denied |
| 93-01 | Randy T. Nielsen vs. Utah Dept. of Natural Resources |
Hunting and fishing licenses | Appeal granted |
| 93-02 | John Pace vs. Dept. of Corrections |
Monitoring of inmate phone calls | Appeal granted |
| 93-03 | James N. Haywood vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Records relating to criminal charges | Appeal denied |
| 93-04 | Sue Cherry vs. Utah State University |
Tenure retention records | Appeal granted |
| 93-05 | Kenneth L. Gray vs. Dept. of Human Resources |
Records regarding a meeting | Appeal denied |
| 93-06 | Equifax Services, Inc. vs. Utah Dept. of Public Safety, Driver's License Division |
Drivers license database | Appeal granted |
| 93-07 | ACLU vs. O. Lane McCotter, executive director of the Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Information regarding new inmate phone system | Appeal denied |
| 94-01 | Karl William Winsness vs. Salt Lake City Corporation |
Police "no knock - no announce warrants," "high risk arrests and searches," and "major incident responses." | Appeal denied |
| 94-02 | Julian Dean Hatch vs. Utah State Div. of Parks and Recreation |
Records regarding archeological digs and research done at Coombs site, Anasazi State Park | Appeal denied |
| 94-03 | Salt Lake City vs. Utah Dept. of Employment Security |
Number of employees for each business | Appeal granted |
| 94-04 | Deseret News vs. University of Utah |
Cold fusion licensing documents | Appeal denied |
| 94-05 | Linda A. Watson vs. Utah Dept. of Human Services, Offices of Liability Management |
Resolution Assistance Committee report regarding petitioner's minor children | Appeal partially granted |
| 94-06 | Michael R. Weibel vs. Logan City |
Police report and city agreement | Appeal partially granted |
| 94-07 | Linda A. Watson vs Utah Dept. of Human Resources, Division of Family Services |
Records relating to petitioner's children | Appeal denied |
| 94-08 | William Remine vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Policies, a list of inmates, and a list of staff | Appeal partially granted |
| 94-09 | Sassy M. Fink and KSTU vs. Utah State Hospital |
Medical records and investigation records of an injury-causing incident | Appeal partially granted |
| 94-10 | William Remine vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Records regarding Appellant that are classified as "protected." | Appeal denied |
| 94-11 | William Remine vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Records of the Board of Pardons regarding Appellant that are classified as "protected." | Appeal denied |
| 94-12 | Abigail W. Delfausse vs. Utah State University |
Appellant's personnel file classified "protected." | Appeal granted |
| 94-13 | United Television Inc., a Delaware
Corporation, aba KTVX Channel 4 vs. Board of Pardons and Parole |
Video tape regarding assault of Howard W. Hunter | Appeal denied |
| 94-14 | Thomas R. Garcia vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Fee waiver for medical records | Appeal granted |
| 94-15 | Linda A. Watson vs. Utah Dept. of Human Services, Division of Family Services |
Two letters from Dr. Kevin Gully (a supervising therapist for minor children of petitioner) and a complete unredacted letter of a third party. | Appeal denied |
| 94-16 | Salt Lake City vs. Industrial Commission of Utah |
Records relating to LaMar C. Macklin in the Matter of LaMar C. Macklin v. Salt Lake City Corporation before the UADD | Appeal granted |
| 94-17 | Roger E. Penman vs. Utah Dept. of Corrections |
Supplemental Reports and Investigative Reports concerning a disciplinary case | Appeal denied |